Welcome, Guest
Username: Password: Remember me

TOPIC: Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell

Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell 1 year 1 day ago #20735

There has been quite a bit of talk about relapse recently across all forums. To me this was entirely expected as with Indian generics appearing in mid December, Jan-Mar was a busy treatment time with SVR12 success and failures starting to appear in bulk in July. Online conversations have a selection bias in that cured patients move on, leaving patients with relapse behind. You can prove that to yourself here by using the forum search tool and selecting a term like "treatment" and then "posts older than 6 months ago" and sorted by views.

fixhepc.com/forum/search.html?query=trea...s&childforums=1&ids=

Here you will see a lot of names you don't recognise, and some that you will. Many of these patients don't post anymore because they have been cured of HCV so our forum is no longer relevant. It's sad to see people go, but I'm happy to know HCV forums have become irrelevant in their lives.

We are active following 448 consecutive patients for reporting purposes. We are following more, but this group of 448 represents a real world sample, chosen before any results were known to ensure it would be representative.

The numbers are now high enough that not a lot of change will be seen. The little grey bars at the top of the graph indicate the 95% confidence intervals. As you can see the more results there are the narrower this range (shorter bar) and it is 20:1 that the "real" result falls inside this range.





So we can see that SVR rates in GT1 are in the mid nineties, and for GT3 in the mid eighties. 323/448 are now at or past the SVR12 point with 50% (224/448) now having SVR4 (or more) results to hand.



What we can also see is that SVR4 is 96.4% durable through to SVR12 with the overall average SVR4 slipping from 91.1% (204/224) to 88.6% (163/184) so if you get SVR4 there is only a 3.6% chance you won't get SVR12 (the odds are now 27:1 in your favour).

Finally the rates of treatment experience and cirrhosis are high compared to manufacturer trials, so there is a degree of negative selection bias. In GT3 we have 38% cirrhosis and 45% past treatment experience (in the easy to treat PEG/Riba GT) so it's not entirely unexpected that we are not seeing the 90% suggested by the originator trials (the easy to cure patients got cured by PEG/Riba). A long term observation in medicine is that real world results are always a bit worse than what the trials suggest.

One of the really good reasons not to be involved in HCV treatment was the 100% certainty that SVR rates of < 100% predict some patients will fail. Individual relapses are heartbreaking, and to be frank I admire the stamina and fortitude of those doctors who had to treat using PEG/Riba given the much lower SVR rates, but to my eyes the rebels have been well served by generics.
YMMV
Last Edit: 1 year 1 day ago by James-Freeman-facebook.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Chapel, coral, Violet, 2b, mgalbrai, Paul-Jarman-facebook, sabrecat, Ariel, Gaj, Lynne-Francis-facebook, Tina-Hill-facebook, beaches, isaing4, Hieupham, re_roll, Hazel, Tommy, MtGoat, Fara, Matt-Kenney-google and this user have 4 others thankyou

Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell 1 year 1 day ago #20737

  • Sven
  • Sven's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Elite Member
  • Posts: 265
  • Thank you received: 955
  • Karma: 12
Much appreciated, grateful for your time on this.
In good health to all in treatment.
Contracted HCV 1980's
Geno Type 1a
F3 ( doc says once treated I'll be F2 maybe F1)
Meds shipped 6/17/2016 arrived early 7/2016

Viral count - 3,471,080

4 week quantitative bloods: August 17, 2016. I have been diagnosed as <15 (told undetected)

8 week quantitative bloods: September 14th. I have been diagnosed as <15 (told undetected)

11 week PCR RNA Qualitative bloods: September 26th 2016 - Undetected

December 19th 2016: Cured!
Viral count: zero!!!
The administrator has disabled public write access.
The following user(s) said Thank You: James-Freeman-facebook, Ariel, Meg

Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell 1 year 1 day ago #20738

  • splitdog
  • splitdog's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Platinum Member
  • Posts: 338
  • Thank you received: 624
  • Karma: 9
Fantastic wealth of real info. ;)
This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Genotype 3
VL 4,100,000
ALT 101 AST 71
Treatment Naive
Started Sof/Dac Jan 12, 2016
VL= <15 4 weeks in. AST/ALT normal.
VL=UNDETECTED 8 weeks in.
SVR4= Virus back. 3,300,000
1 week later= 20,741,477

I know I will be cured.
Thank you Jesus.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
The following user(s) said Thank You: James-Freeman-facebook, Ariel, Lynne-Francis-facebook, beaches

Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell 1 year 1 day ago #20739

  • rightsaidfred
  • rightsaidfred's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Senior Member
  • G3a infected 40 years ago
  • Posts: 66
  • Thank you received: 206
  • Karma: 6
Morning all,

I don't understand the bit about the little grey bars. What is a 'confidence rate'? Can someone who understands statistics please explain?

Thanks, RSF
G3a. Probably infected 40 years ago.
Diagnosed July 2015
7/7/2015: ALP 69, ALT 209, WBC 5.8, VL 40,000. Fibroscan 9.5 Kpa.
Commenced treatment Sof/Dac (Natco Pharma) 24 wks in Feb 16
VL UND @ 4 wks, 12 wks

EOT 6/7/16
SVR 12
SVR 24

PHEW! Thank you so much Dr James, Monkmeds and all at Fixhepc
The administrator has disabled public write access.
The following user(s) said Thank You: James-Freeman-facebook, Ariel, Gaj

Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell 1 year 1 day ago #20740

  • rohcvfighter
  • rohcvfighter's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Platinum Member
  • Vindecat de HCV cu med. generice. Cured with generics HCV drugs.
  • Posts: 363
  • Thank you received: 1446
  • Karma: 13
Hello Dr. Freeman,

thank you for these explanations. Although 100% cure rate would be a wonderful success rate, a success rate of more than 90% is also an impressive one.
I believe that any HCV patient who is currently on treatment with generics (or will be on treatment) has 2 key questions in mind:
- Am I among the ~95% who will get cured?
- Are the generics really effective?

For the moment (no mass treatment being deployed worldwide) the level of anxiety is somehow high among the patients, yet in the following months, with more and more data available about SVR12/24, the level of trust will increase and taking the treatment will be (I hope) something normal in tems of accessibility and confidence.

Cheers,
RHF
In fiecare an HCV ucide peste 500000 oameni.Medicamentele generice pentru hepatita C functioneaza. Nu deveni statistica! Cauta pe Google “medicamente generice pentru hepatita C”.
HCV kills more than 500000 people every year. HCV generic drugs work. Don't become a statistic.
By sharing this Youtube video you might save someone’s life!
My TX: HEPCVIR-L[generic Harvoni]-India
SVR52 achieved
Last Edit: 1 year 1 day ago by rohcvfighter.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
The following user(s) said Thank You: James-Freeman-facebook

Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell 1 year 1 day ago #20741

I don't understand the bit about the little grey bars. What is a 'confidence rate'? Can someone who understands statistics please explain?

I could point you at this en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Binomial_proportion_confidence_interval but the formulas might make your eyes bleed so let's work through it. It's actually pretty easy to understand.

Say we have a coin and we toss it once. It comes up heads. We now have 100% (1/1) heads, but it could just as easily have been 100% tails. It was impossible to get the expected 50:50 result with a single toss, but even with 2 tosses it is 1:4 of being 2 heads, 1:2 of being a head and a tail, and 1:4 of being two tails. With 3 tosses the chances of 3 heads are 1:8, 4 tosses 1:16, 5 tosses 1:32 so you can see that the more we toss the coin the less likely we are to get an "all heads" rubbish result.

If you go to this page: statpages.info/confint.html you can put in 1 for x and 1 for N and get the confidence interval on our single coin toss which is 0.0250 - 1.000 (2.5% to 100%). You can change the values for x (say heads) and N (say tosses) and see what happens.

Now say we toss it 3 times and get 2/3 - 66% heads. The confidence interval is 0.094 - 0.9916 (9.4% to 99.16%)

Now say we toss it 30 times and get 20/30 - still 66% heads. The confidence interval is 0.4719 - 0.8271 (47.19% - 82.71%)

See how the confidence interval gets narrower the more tests we do? I kind of makes sense that the more we test this, the closer we are going to get to the right answer.

Now say we toss it 300 times and get 200/300. Now we have tossed it so many times that random chance starts to evaporate because we have had lots of tries. The confidence interval is now 0.6102 - 0.7198 - narrower again, but....

This interval does not include 0.5 aka 50% aka 50:50 so we can conclude that the coin is loaded.

So in short the more results we have the more confident we are that the value is correct and the confidence interval tells us how much higher or lower the real result could reasonably be if we do an infinite number of trials.

What's "reasonable"?

Reasonable in this case is a mathematical definition because confidence intervals exist at different levels. We have been looking at the 95% confidence interval level that says - with mathematical precision - that 95% of the time, the results will fall within this range.
YMMV
Last Edit: 1 year 1 day ago by James-Freeman-facebook.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
The following user(s) said Thank You: mgalbrai, Ariel, Gaj, isaing4, rohcvfighter, Peach

Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell 1 year 19 hours ago #20745

  • rightsaidfred
  • rightsaidfred's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Senior Member
  • G3a infected 40 years ago
  • Posts: 66
  • Thank you received: 206
  • Karma: 6
Thanks very much for the explanation Dr Freeman

RSF
G3a. Probably infected 40 years ago.
Diagnosed July 2015
7/7/2015: ALP 69, ALT 209, WBC 5.8, VL 40,000. Fibroscan 9.5 Kpa.
Commenced treatment Sof/Dac (Natco Pharma) 24 wks in Feb 16
VL UND @ 4 wks, 12 wks

EOT 6/7/16
SVR 12
SVR 24

PHEW! Thank you so much Dr James, Monkmeds and all at Fixhepc
The administrator has disabled public write access.

Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell 1 year 17 hours ago #20747

  • Matt-Kenney-google
  • Matt-Kenney-google's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Platinum Member
  • Avatar-Gaelic for "Welcome"
  • Posts: 421
  • Thank you received: 1301
  • Karma: 9
Good timing as usual Dr. F :lol:
I was trying to explain to my wife what all the "hullabaloo" about relapsing was about on recent postings and here you come to the rescue, right on time and right to the point. Very helpful. Thank you.

Matt
GT1a; Got it some time in the 70's; Diagnosed @1976
Tx naive
METAVIR: A2-F2
SOT May 18, 2016: CMP: AST 162 ALT 241 VL 13000000
3 weeks after SOT: AST 27 ALT 31 VL 138
Reached EOT Aug. 10, 2016 / Received svr4 results Sept. 20, 2016: AST 22 ALT 24
Hep C RNA "NOT DETECTED"
AS OF 3/20/2017 ,Hep C RNA PCR "NOT DETECTED" THAT'S SVR24!
The administrator has disabled public write access.

Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell 11 months 4 weeks ago #20869

  • sabrecat
  • sabrecat's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Elite Member
  • Posts: 230
  • Thank you received: 607
  • Karma: 5
"Individual relapses are heartbreaking, and to be frank I admire the stamina and fortitude of those doctors who had to treat using PEG/Riba given the much lower SVR rates, but to my eyes the rebels have been well served by generics."

I did imagine an ever so slight look resignation and despair with medicos that had treated me with this stuff - the look of someone chasing their losses on a poker machine and not catching up.

That said though, relapses on generics have proven to be a bit of a lousy time for me, but there was not the 'thank God that's [interferon/riba] over; I can get back to actually doing my work again" aspect about it.

Appears from Dr Freeman's post I am a 14 percenter?



Jeff
GT3a 1990 Failed Inter 1998, comb in 2000. HCC 2012
Started 24/52 Sof/Dac 27th October 2015.
1. Bloods 2 October 2015: AST - 165 (20-40), ALT - 265 (5-40), GGT 189 (5-50)
2, Bloods 20 November 2015: ALT etc normal; VL 19
3. Bloods 8 January 2016: AST - 40, ALT - 59, GGT 48 VL RNA UND
4. EOT 12 April 2016 - blood tests: all is well, CT scan: okay
5. AFP 16 May 2016: 4 ref <11
6. AFP 11 June 2016: 4 ref< 11
7. VL 4th July 2016: DET
8. ultrasound 12th July 2016 - OK
9. Oct16 start treat - June UND
The administrator has disabled public write access.
The following user(s) said Thank You: coral, mgalbrai, Paul-Jarman-facebook, Ariel, isaing4, Mnem

Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell 11 months 4 weeks ago #20872

  • Greedfighter
  • Greedfighter's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Platinum Member
  • Posts: 534
  • Thank you received: 1463
  • Karma: 9
Sabrecat, you have the new Sofosbuvir Velpatasvir generics (Sofvel from Beacon being the first) coming on line that now make Gen3 as curable as Gen 1 :cheer: :+1: We're all getting cured here! Dr. Freeman and Dr. Devsam to the rescue!
Gt 1a, F0, VL 6.5 million, AST 59, ALT 62
Started Twinvir 1/15/16
6 wk. labs, VL UND, AST 27, ALT 20
EOT labs, VL UND, AST 23, ALT 19
SVR 16, VL UND, AST 28, ALT 17
SVR 24, VL UND, 10/8/16
Last Edit: 11 months 4 weeks ago by Greedfighter.
The administrator has disabled public write access.
The following user(s) said Thank You: sabrecat, Ariel, isaing4

Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell 11 months 4 weeks ago #20893

  • Ariel
  • Ariel's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Platinum Member
  • Cured, SVR 24
  • Posts: 995
  • Thank you received: 2736
  • Karma: 22
Thinking of you Sabrecat
Yup totes get what you feel about the old relapse having been there myself like many others too, and I am sure you are totally focused again on getting the bugger out for once and for all. I won't ever forget that feeling of sheer determination at relapse and the machine I turned into on a mission that I was never gonna quit. New meds coming through thank Gawd, and things are moving so much faster now too. Another better thing than those poopy old days.
All relapsers have my heart and everyone here I can see are getting behind anyone who has not cleared easily on this easy DAA tx we have nowadays.
Sabrecat, it is in reach I am certain.
Love from Ariel #flower
Gen 1a
Peg/inf/riba 2012(!?!) stopped at Week 43 due to potassium level ext. low plus other issues (relapse at week 4 post tx, VL120,000) many secondary niggles eg. adenomas.
pre sof/led VL 240,000 Fibrosc F0
Day 25 VL <30
Day 32 UND
Week 10 UND
EOT UND ALT 11 AST 17 GGT 19
SVR4 UND ALT 10 AST 16 GGT 13
SVR8 UND ALT <9 AST 16 GGT 15
SVR12 UND ALT 14 AST 19 GGT 12 Bili 5
EOT +18 ALT13 AST 20 GGT 9 Bili 5
EOT +21 ALT 11 AST 15
Cured at SVR12
Dysplasia Adenoma removed Aug '16
SVR24 UND ALT 11 AST16
The administrator has disabled public write access.
The following user(s) said Thank You: coral, mgalbrai, sabrecat, Lynne-Francis-facebook

Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell 3 months 2 weeks ago #24341

  • Kathleen-Krowchuk-facebook
  • Kathleen-Krowchuk-facebook's Avatar
WOW so glad I found this site.. :) :)
The administrator has disabled public write access.

Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell 3 months 2 weeks ago #24344

  • Mnem
  • Mnem's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Senior Member
  • the fox knows many things, but the hedgehog knows one big thing
  • Posts: 65
  • Thank you received: 130
  • Karma: 0
Come on in Kathleen, the water's fine!
G2, infected ~1971?
Diagnosed HVnon-A non-B 1980s, revised to HVC 1990's.
Treatment naive. Fibroscan & bloods all normal ranges.
Viral load 7million,
began Redemption trial4, generic Sof/Vel 2017.
week4 - virus UND
week12 EOT - UND *)*
now marching to SVR12
The administrator has disabled public write access.
The following user(s) said Thank You: coral, mgalbrai, Gaj, Lynne-Francis-facebook, Iain

Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell 3 months 1 week ago #24355

  • coral
  • coral's Avatar
  • Offline
  • Platinum Member
  • Posts: 416
  • Thank you received: 1123
  • Karma: 14
Hello Kathleen and Welcome...... #flower #flower
G1a probably early 1980's, Biopsy F1(2010), F2-F3(2015). VL 5+mill; 2+mill (2014) Tx naive. Accessed Sof/Led through Dr Freeman at GP2U and Buyers Club (lifesavers!!!)
Commenced tx 12/11/15. 9 wk: VL <15 Detected but LFT = Normal 12 week results: UND (Yay!) Due to slow response commenced Sof/Dac 4 Feb for 12 weeks. EOT @ 24 weeks 27 April 2016. (With thanks to Dr Freeman et al). SVR11 result: VL 1,950,000. It's back!
New tx 030916 (Viekira Pak, Solvadi, Ribavirin UND @ 111116. EOT 170217.
SVR12 UND Hooray...
The administrator has disabled public write access.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Iain

Real World Generic Cure Rates in a Nutshell 3 months 1 week ago #24373

Hep C generics are probably one of the only exceptions to the rule "If it seems to good to be true, it must be".

In the case of generics, the 100,000% markup on the originator medications is what allows the prices to be 1-2%

Even if you don't treat, it's nice to know you could, if you wanted to.

As a patient, it's got to be a cruel and unusual punishment to know that a cure exists, but not for me.
YMMV
The administrator has disabled public write access.
The following user(s) said Thank You: Tina-Hill-facebook
Time to create page: 0.240 seconds

Copyright © 2015-2017 FixHepC

Back to Top