Klhilde's suggestion is an excellent one, and should be the first change imo. At least it will give people arriving at the forum an indication of the proper structure of the forum. Wrt individual threads, any posts deemed sufficiently relevant and useful long-term should be made into stickys. If it's a paticularly important post, as many of Dr Freeman's are (most of which are all over the place and not easily found at the mo), either a 'reports of distinction' type of section, or into the FAQ's.
I know it's easy for me to say, me not being a mod who has to do it all, but a general tidy up of the threads wouldn't be a bad thing. All of us regs have been guilty of going offtopic/posting in the wrong threads. On the other hand, as others have pointed out, we want to keep the friendly and 'human' aspects of the forum. Some unrelated forums I'm involved with are over-moderated. Little Hitler syndrome springs to mind
.